

Critic speaks earnestly about the bad he sees in the good book
There is enough nonsense in this world, and it is time we got
serious about something important. How about the Bible, that complex, huge book that has directed
Christians and Jews for centuries? I was going to say the Bible had inspired Christians and Jews
for centuries, but there are some Christians and Jews who possibly
will never be inspired, even by the Bible. So, when a man with strong views on the Bible came to town
recently, I decided to sit down with him. His name is C. Dennis
McKinsey, and he is an atheist. He thinks the Bible is full of
contradictions, mistakes, lies and deceit. He wants others to
understand that he is not anti-Bible - he just wants to expose
things that are wrong, he says. A father of three, McKinsey writes to radio stations and newspapers
to get his main points across. In his view, the Bible doesn't
make sense, and it is rife with screwed-up thinking and bias against
women and homosexuals. He has written a book called "An Encyclopedia of Biblical
Errancy" (Prometheus Books, $51), which has sold about 2,000
copies since 1995. He is a bold advocate who will not retreat
from his premise that the Bible is wrong, especially in its assertion
that Jesus Christ is the incarnation of God. He was in the Twin Cities recently to speak to the annual banquet
of Minnesota Atheists, a group of about 200 people who have engaged
the mostly Christian culture in the Twin Cities for a couple of
decades. If you asked to talk with McKinsey, the session could go on
for days, perhaps weeks. When he sits down at a table with me,
he begins to speak earnestly, and he does not stop until I halt
him abruptly. "Why are you doing this?" I ask him. "You say
you want to reach fundamentalist Christians, but do you actually
believe you will change anyone's mind?" "You can reach some of them," McKinsey says through
clenched teeth. But does he reach them in the dozens of debates he has done
across the United States? "I do it because it needs to be done - real, real bad." McKinsey's companion and driver, Twin Cities atheist Steven
Petersen, saves the day. "As atheists, our real purpose,"
Petersen said, "is to civilize religion. There is a lack
of critical thinking. We aren't anti-religion." That fits with my understanding of atheist organizations -
they just want a fair shake. Some atheists have been hurt by religion.
Others have been raised by parents who are critical-reasoners,
who taught their children to think things through before they
jump on someone's stage and start singing the praises of a deity. Atheists are simply part of the religious scene. And their
best work is in the analysis of religion, good and bad. Notice
that McKinsey is not very concerned about mainline religion, which
watches its clergy and professionals quite closely. He is more
concerned with fundamentalist Christians who often will quote
the Bible but usually under a particular bias that renders it
useless to anyone outside the faith. McKinsey is also full of cliches: "Some aspects of Christianity are dangerous," he
says, or "Man has progressed in spite of the Bible, not because
of it," or "You cannot support homosexuality and believe
the Bible" or "The Bible is its own worst enemy." In real life, McKinsey is a vocational counselor at a high
school outside Columbus, Ohio. He has a wife and three children.
But clearly the errors in the Bible are what drive his life. He
had no training in religious matters as a child. But when he studied
philosophy in college, the juices began to flow. Then a friend
gave him a copy of "Good News for Modern Man," a loosely
translated Bible designed for easy reading. McKinsey was hooked.
He read the Good Book from beginning to end and found it full
of inconsistencies. "The Bible has more holes in it than a back-door screen,"
McKinsey says. His main endeavor is writing a monthly newsletter called Biblical
Errancy, which he sends to hundreds of people. They respond with
letters, and McKinsey then has a chance to blast them by pointing
out the biblical errors. I ask McKinsey what he regards as the two greatest errors in
the Bible. He answers without hesitation: "That the Bible
is inerrant and that Jesus is the incarnation of God."
Clark D. Morphew
Posted For July 25, 1998