
It's time to end Palestinian wretchedness, pain
The peace process in Israel is at a standstill again. Israel
continues to push into Palestinian territory, building huge housing
complexes and forcing Arabs further into despair. In every part of the Palestinian population, Christian and
Muslim alike, there is a continuing agony as they continue to
live in captivity without hope and always behind the barricades
of hatred and malice. For 10 years, ever since the Palestinian uprising known as
the Intifada, the Israeli government has systematically oppressed
an entire people. To complicate matters, the international media
have done little to convey the squalid conditions of the Palestinian
refugee camps, the injustices against working people or the brutality
of living without hope. Yes, there have been moments of hope when Palestinian and Israeli
leaders reached agreements, shook hands and promised a future
of peace and prosperity. But always the Palestinians remain in
refugee camps, and their only hope is that relief agencies will
keep them one step ahead of starvation. One relief agency official, Tom Getman, executive director
of World Vision, Jerusalem, calls the situation in Israel a "murky
vortex" with Palestinians being drawn steadily deeper into
a subhuman existence. Getman says there is a a growing antipathy
to the anti-peace measures of Israeli President Benjamin Netanyahu. Now progressive Jews, Christians and Muslims living in Israel
are beginning to see that politics is not the answer, that conservative
leadership in Israel will continue to force Palestinians into
oppression. Further, it is clear that Palestinian leadership does
little to improve the situation. Into this void of leadership comes a coalition of relief agencies:
World Vision, Lutheran World Relief, Catholic Relief, CARE and
many others. Their job is to feed people, build adequate housing
and create a mechanism that will allow peace to flow like a raging
river. But politics works against peace in Israel. The relief agencies
want to do more than feed people. They want to bring the two sides
together, not in huge international meetings that promise change,
but in small groups that will begin the real work of reconciliation.
Even that effort is stymied by reality. Of the 63 projects run by international relief organizations,
only four are aimed at forgiveness, reconciliation and economic
development. The other 59 projects simply rush to stem the tide
of illness and hunger that plague the refugee camps day by day. The only hope is for Israelis to stop demonizing Palestinians,
to see them as human beings who yearn for the same opportunities
offered to those living on the other side of the barricades and
check points. Of course, that works both ways, but it is more difficult for
the oppressed to reach out in peace to an oppressor. But relief
officials working there say that is the only way peace will be
reached in the Middle East. It all goes back to 1948, when the state of Israel was established
following the Israeli-Arab war. Then hundreds of Palestinian villages
were bulldozed or confiscated; estimates claim that about $200
billion of property was taken by the new Israeli government. The
spoils of war, some said. The Palestinians will recover, international
observers said. But they have never recovered in nearly 50 years of brutal
oppression. As the terrible years roll by, the Israeli government
continues to confiscate Palestinian land for Jewish housing developments. Getman says that if the Israeli government is successful, all
Christians, Muslims, and secular or progressive Jews will be shoved
out of the Holy Land. That will leave the territory to the ultra-Orthodox
Jewish faction creating a Zionist ghetto, an Orthodox Jewish tourist
attraction where people of other world religions can visit but
never stay. The tragedy is, Israel is the birthplace of Judaism, Christianity
and Islam - and because of that diversity, it belongs to the world.
It is difficult to imagine that any people could enjoy living
in such a sterile environment, all driven by the same principles,
values and history. Yet the oppression continues and in some ways is encouraged
by the billions of dollars of support from the U.S. government.
Meanwhile, Israel, far from being destitute, is the 16th-largest
economy in the world, according to Getman. But that's politics. Meanwhile, the alternatives - actions
such as forgiveness, love and reconciliation - are not always
trusted by people living either in power or in misery. But Tom
Getman of World Vision says politics hasn't worked for half a
century. "Peace will be accomplished day by day through the unglamorous
struggle for the millions of human beings whose wretched condition
is brought about by politics," Getman says. That sounds as if we're all involved in this struggle. As the
tide turns against oppression in Israel, where will we stand as
a nation, as religious people, as pilgrims praying for a just
world? Clark D. MorphewNovember 15, 1997