

Another culture offers a fresh take on stale church conventions
As many of you might remember, I have written before suggesting
that church conventions cost too much and waste a lot of time. I've covered many church conventions, some as long as 10 days,
and I can tell you, the amount of money being spent at these gatherings
is huge. Some conventions, for instance, have elaborate systems so that
delegates can vote by pushing a button while a computer records
the votes and shows them piling up on screens around the room. Years ago, delegates simply held up a red card for yes and
a green card for no. Then counters went from row to row adding
up the votes - a less expensive system but not very efficient. I was thinking about church conventions the other day and dreading
the summer season, because that's when Christians will gather
all over the country for their deliberations. Both the Lutherans
and the Episcopalians are meeting in Philadelphia. The Presbyterians
will be meeting, and so will the United Church of Christ. The
United Methodists must be meeting somewhere, too. Oh my, I thought,
the nightmare would be having to attend them all. Then I remembered a letter I received from Carl Volz, a church
historian at Luther Theological Seminary in St. Paul, Minn. Volz
spent six months in Papua New Guinea on sabbatical in 1989. During
that time, the people of Papua New Guinea were preparing for their
church convention. Contrast Volz's account of that gathering with
some of those held in America: "Papua New Guinea (PNG) must be one of the most primitive
outposts of the Third World. There are few roads because of the
mountainous terrain. There is no road from the capital city, Port
Moresby, to the rest of the island. All travel is either by small
airplane or around the shoreline by sea or on foot through jungles. "A convention site was located along the seacoast, which
was more easily accessible than inland. This was a convention
of the PNG Lutheran Church, which is the dominant religion. The
date was set a year ahead in order to have ample time for preparations. "These (preparations) included clearing a large piece
of land in the jungle to build a meri-house, or dormitory for
women, and a man-house. These were two large two-story buildings
with no rooms - just a large floor on which to sleep. "In addition to this, another large piece of land was
cleared to plant kai-kais, or sweet potatoes, to feed the assembly.
The building materials came from the jungle itself. "Besides the two dormitories, they built a very high speaker's
platform at another clearing. None of this cost anyone anything.
The material was free, and the labor was volunteer. When the time
for the convention drew near, word went out through drummers and
other communication networks that the date would have to be postponed
for two weeks because the sweet potatoes were not ripe yet. "I was disappointed, as I had planned to attend the earlier
date but could not make the new date. About 600 delegates attended
the meeting, which cost almost nothing. The food and lodging cost
nothing to anyone (perhaps they needed some sweet potato seedlings
but they are as bountiful as grass). "It may be that they had a mau-mau or pig roast (on hot
coals in the ground) and that would have cost someone. The transportation
by boat or foot would have cost nothing as people have their own
canoes." Volz tells his students this story not to suggest that Americans
could endure a similar convention but to contrast two very different
cultures. Still, the idea of dormitories instead of hotel rooms does
intrigue me. That way, the delegates and church officers could
all be together in the same place. It would be easier to find
people for me to interview. And certainly there would be some
great late-night conversations. And the sweet potatoes? Hmmm! Not for 10 days straight. Bring
on the drummers.
Clark D. Morphew
Posted For March 8, 1997